PageWeave/Design

Prompts / Redesign Critique

3 Prompt promptcritiquereviewauditdesign .md

Redesign Critique

Structured teardown before any code changes

Critique this page before we change anything: [URL or paste HTML].

Audit against each dimension, one finding per line, severity-tagged [HIGH]/[MED]/[LOW]:

1. Typography — scale consistency, measure (45–75ch), line-height, hierarchy by
   size+weight+spacing (not size alone), font character vs generic.
2. Color — dominant/accent balance, semantic misuse, contrast failures, timid palettes.
3. Spacing — system vs random values, symmetry, density matching the content's needs.
4. Composition — alignment logic, asymmetry used with intent, grid-breaking elements.
5. Motion — purpose, orchestration, reduced-motion handling.
6. Honesty — invented features, fake urgency, placeholder content pretending to be real.

Then:
- The ONE change that would most improve the page (and why it beats the others).
- Three quick wins (< 10 lines of CSS each).
- What is already good — don't fix what isn't broken.

Do NOT rewrite code yet. Findings first, I'll pick what to act on.